No announcement yet.

Re: Review Time-line for Journals

This topic is closed.
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Re: Review Time-line for Journals


    My experience is as follows:

    Some journals (e.g. Clinical Biomechanics) ask reviewers to turn round
    manuscripts fairly rapidly (e.g. three weeks).

    At the beginning of 1996 the Journal of Biomechanics tightened up its
    policy on length of papers, with the declared aim of reducing
    publication times. I submitted a Technical Note to them in early 1996
    which they had the final version of in September 1996. It was
    published in the April 1997 issue.

    Some journals, though not consistently, publish with the paper the
    dates it was first received and the date of final acceptance. These
    give the vital clues about the length of the review/revision process
    and the delay between acceptance and publication. I wish all journals
    published this information on all papers. Perhaps journal editors
    would like to comment.

    The September 1998 issue of J.Biomech. has papers received in final
    form between January and June 1998. The Dec 1998 (!) issue of Applied
    Ergonomics has papers which spent between six months and two years in
    the review / revision process, with most being received in final form
    in late 1997. Ergonomics certainly used to publish this information
    but appears to have stopped doing so., MSc, Eur Erg
    Ergonomics and Work Psychology Section
    Health and Safety Laboratory, Broad Lane, Sheffield, S3 7HQ, UK
    Tel +44 114 289 2594; Fax +44 114 289 2526
    HSE home page:

    ______________________________ Reply Separator _________________________________
    Subject: Review Time-line for Journals
    Author: Clifford Larkins at Internet-Gateway
    Date: 22/10/1998 12:11

    Dear Group:
    Can anyone speak to the issue of review time-lines for authors who
    submit to the various journals in the field of biomechanics. It appears
    that the waiting period varies greatly from one journal to the next. I
    would also like to know if there is any policy governing how long an author
    should expect to wait, either by the journal itself or by the international
    biomechanics groups.

    Clifford Larkins, Ph.D.

    To unsubscribe send UNSUBSCRIBE BIOMCH-L to
    For information and archives:

    To unsubscribe send UNSUBSCRIBE BIOMCH-L to
    For information and archives: